This blog might have been already made, and i know that this happened a whole season ago, but I remember seeing somewhere that Hershel was meant to die in Beside the Dying Fire, but because Dale died, he lived. I'm not sure if this is completely accurate, but I do remember seeing it somewhere.

So does this mean that if Dale didn't die, he would have lost his leg in Seed, but anyway this leads to my question, who would you rather have? Dale or Hershel? I can't decide, I prefered Dale in Season 2 and didn't like Hershel in season 2, but Hershel has become one of my favourites in season 3, so what do you all think?