Well... this topic is about Luke, but we need to talk about Kenny first... don't kill me, Ice Cream fans...
Kenny was supposed to die in No Time Left, but some friki from TellTale said "wait! what if we bring him back in S2?" and so they did. But then it had to be like "he is dead, dude, there's not chance he's alive, he had only ONE bullet and there was a lot of walkers, blah blah blah". But Tadá! he's alive (at least in some playthroughs). Whatever, he came back in S2, and we all thought he was dead... but he wasn't.
NOW LET'S TALK ABOUT LUKE:
He was the "nice guy" that everybody loves :D (me too :'D), and IT WAS HIS FREAKING BIRTHDAY, GUYS! and he just died in the middle of the episode... no at the end, not fighting against walkers NO! he just drowned in the frozen lake. A stupid death, I think. Yes, he sacrificed his life for Clem's if you decide to try save him... but... still... it's just unfair
Everybody loved Luke... and I'm sure TellTale loved him too. But some peoples still loving Kenny over him... and they just couldn't let his fate in the Kenny fans' hands.
All the time it was about Kenny vs Luke, Pizza vs Ice Cream (ice cream 4ever ;D), but then Jane showed up and ruined the episode D: But... maybe she didn't. Maybe it was better that way... and do you know why? because now Luke is not determinant. Yes, determinant characters doesn't last. Now we know he is dead in all the playthroughs... or he is alive.
Now my evidence:
Kenny was supposed to die to show up in S2
Kenny fans wouldn't doubt in saving Kenny and killing Luke
Bonnie and Luke was the same time in the water ans she was alright... she didn't die... so why did Luke die? (my answer: she hit him accidentally in the head, leaving him unconscious. Look, if you try to save him, he lasted more time awake...)
Now is when you say: "But even if he killed the walker/woke up before drawing, and even if he get out of the water, he would die of hypothermia. He would be too wet to start a fire, he would die, blah blah blah". NOW, do you remember all those theories about Kenny was alive... and they well all right? they had to make it more... I don't find the word... incredible? you get it. They didn't want us to make this theory (but I'm writing it lol). We had to think he is dead... but I don't think so. He had his machete and a gun when he fell. He could kill the walker and scape yet. And then what? What if he had not enough bullets? What if his hands was too numb to grab his machete? I admit, it would be too perfect if he's alive, but hey! sometimes in The Walking Dead happens this kind of thing: AJ's father is Alvin (they're too similar), when it was almost sure that Carver was, Kenny survived to the walkers, that stuff (and sometimes stupid things happens, like Omid's death D':) and Luke would have to be very... lucky... to survive.
Well, even if he gets out of the water, he wouldn't start a fire, everything he'd touch would get wet. So someone would have to help him. There are a lot of characters that could help him: Christa, that could be around there, looking for Clementine, Lilly, like a lonely survivor, the Family (Randy, Patricia and Gil [they said they were in the north so...], some bandit or a character from 400 days, or maybe a new character...)
And he just said it to Clementine: "I'd come back to you"
Coincidence? I don't think so.
Tell me what you think guys :D