• Alright I know how a lot of people compare the comics to the tv show but what about character-character wise? This poll will be pitting the comic characters vs the tv character, which one do you like better? If you don't like a certain character in either form just hit neither...and if you want to explain why one is better than then other

    Which Rick do you like better?
     
    292
     
    685
     
    466
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 1443 people voted.
    Which Carl do you like better?
     
    715
     
    160
     
    51
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 926 people voted.
    Which Lori Grimes do you like better?
     
    454
     
    531
     
    266
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 1251 people voted.
    Which Andrea do you like better?
     
    854
     
    59
     
    28
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 941 people voted.
    Which Maggie do you like better?
     
    180
     
    717
     
    13
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 910 people voted.
    Which Glenn do you like better?
     
    153
     
    734
     
    14
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 901 people voted.
    Which Dale do you like better?
     
    362
     
    458
     
    52
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 872 people voted.
    Which Shane Walsh do you like better?
     
    34
     
    794
     
    53
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 881 people voted.
    Which Tyreese do you like better?
     
    578
     
    280
     
    15
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 873 people voted.
    Which Hershel Greene do you like better?
     
    60
     
    804
     
    13
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 877 people voted.
    Which Morgan Jones do you like better?
     
    103
     
    690
     
    37
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 830 people voted.
    Which Carol do you like better?
     
    82
     
    770
     
    29
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 881 people voted.
    Which Michonne do you like better?
     
    227
     
    572
     
    31
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 830 people voted.
    Which Governor do you like better?(as a villain obviously)
     
    307
     
    485
     
    28
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 820 people voted.
    Which Bob Stookey do you like better?
     
    31
     
    637
     
    82
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 750 people voted.
    Which Abraham Ford do you like better?
     
    433
     
    298
     
    28
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 759 people voted.
    Which Eugene Porter do you like better?
     
    476
     
    222
     
    45
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 743 people voted.
    Which Rosita Espinosa do you like better?
     
    102
     
    576
     
    56
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 734 people voted.
    Which Martinez do you like better?
     
    177
     
    423
     
    85
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 685 people voted.
    Which Axel do you like better?
     
    501
     
    155
     
    43
     

    The poll was created at 19:54 on April 14, 2014, and so far 699 people voted.
      Loading editor
    • a few more 

      Which Jim do you like better?
       
      61
       
      442
       
      75
       

      The poll was created at 21:16 on April 14, 2014, and so far 578 people voted.
      Which Amy do you like better?
       
      72
       
      376
       
      126
       

      The poll was created at 21:16 on April 14, 2014, and so far 574 people voted.
      Which Lilly do you like better?
       
      417
       
      61
       
      85
       

      The poll was created at 21:37 on April 14, 2014, and so far 563 people voted.
      Which Sophia do you like Better?
       
      537
       
      32
       
      50
       

      The poll was created at 21:16 on April 14, 2014, and so far 619 people voted.
      Which Otis do you like better?
       
      152
       
      331
       
      77
       

      The poll was created at 21:16 on April 14, 2014, and so far 560 people voted.
      Which Patricia do you like better?
       
      280
       
      100
       
      161
       

      The poll was created at 21:16 on April 14, 2014, and so far 541 people voted.
        Loading editor
    • I like all TV Series better, except Michonne, Carol and Lori :)

        Loading editor
    • I prefer all the Comic characters over the TV characters, except for Hershel.

        Loading editor
    • Daryl vs Dwight :P

        Loading editor
    • How about Merle?

        Loading editor
    • Good blog♫ I like Tv characters better, except Sophia, i choose comic♫ As for TG, Jim, Amy, Lilly, Abraham and Bob, i choose neither♫

        Loading editor
    • Teamdaryl wrote:
      How about Merle?

      Merle doesn't exist in TWD comics.

        Loading editor
    • i know it is rumoured that chase vasser has been cast as a villain - looking at him, he might be negan - does anyone have any thoughts on this?

        Loading editor
    • The only characters I like more in the show are Hershel and Shane.

        Loading editor
    • Hershel, Shane, and Carol are the only characters I like in the TV series more. Rosita will probably be on there as well if she gets development.

        Loading editor
    • Adding some more TV versus Comic stuff.

      Lizzie/Mike or Ben/Billy?(Which was handled better to you?)
       
      54
       
      317
       
      13
       

      The poll was created at 18:09 on April 30, 2014, and so far 384 people voted.
      Which Marauders do you like better?
       
      29
       
      295
       
      17
       

      The poll was created at 18:08 on April 30, 2014, and so far 341 people voted.
      Which Final Battle between The Prison & the Governor did you like the best?
       
      289
       
      93
       
      6
       

      The poll was created at 18:14 on April 30, 2014, and so far 388 people voted.
      Did you think TV Rick should of lost his hand like his Comic Counterpart did during the Prison Arc?
       
      65
       
      245
       
      24
       
      76
       

      The poll was created at 18:13 on April 30, 2014, and so far 410 people voted.
      Are you glad Judith outlived her Comic Counterpart or do you think she should of died at the Prison?
       
      231
       
      151
       
      42
       

      The poll was created at 18:16 on April 30, 2014, and so far 424 people voted.
        Loading editor
    • omg comic book lori is so much more annoying someone tell me why does she have a majority of the votes??

        Loading editor
    • Comic: Rick, Andrea, Glenn, Dale, Abraham, Eugene, Axel, Lilly, Sophia, Maggie, Tyreese

      TV: Shane, Hershel, Morgan, Carol, Michonne, The Governor, Bob, Martinez, Jim, Amy, Otis, Lizzie & Mika, The Claimers

      Neither: Patricia, Rosita, Carl, Lori

        Loading editor
    • Ddogpersonthing wrote:
      omg comic book lori is so much more annoying someone tell me why does she have a majority of the votes??

      Because Lori in the TV series was an annoying bitch. Much worse than Lori from the comic series.

        Loading editor
    • How is TV Eugene almost beating comic Eugene? That makes no sense what-so-ever. Shane and Hershel are the only people I prefer in the TV Series, everyone else feels like lackluster versions.

        Loading editor
    • Gravelord wrote: How is TV Eugene almost beating comic Eugene? That makes no sense what-so-ever. Shane and Hershel are the only people I prefer in the TV Series, everyone else feels like lackluster versions.

      Hard to believe that any of the TV versions are winning.

        Loading editor
    • SilentGlaive wrote:

      Gravelord wrote: How is TV Eugene almost beating comic Eugene? That makes no sense what-so-ever. Shane and Hershel are the only people I prefer in the TV Series, everyone else feels like lackluster versions.

      Hard to believe that any of the TV versions are winning.

      Kaley, you may hate the show, but even you can't deny that characters like Hershel, Shane, and Bob were done much better in the show. Don't be biased like that. :/

        Loading editor
    • InsaneHippo wrote:
      SilentGlaive wrote:

      Gravelord wrote: How is TV Eugene almost beating comic Eugene? That makes no sense what-so-ever. Shane and Hershel are the only people I prefer in the TV Series, everyone else feels like lackluster versions.

      Hard to believe that any of the TV versions are winning.
      Kaley, you may hate the show, but even you can't deny that characters like Hershel, Shane, and Bob were done much better in the show. Don't be biased like that. :/

      I agree with Hippo♫ And don't forget about Carol in the tv♪ She's much better than the comic version IMHO♪ The "Ben and Billy" arc in the tv is also better♪

        Loading editor
    • InsaneHippo wrote:

      SilentGlaive wrote:

      Gravelord wrote: How is TV Eugene almost beating comic Eugene? That makes no sense what-so-ever. Shane and Hershel are the only people I prefer in the TV Series, everyone else feels like lackluster versions.

      Hard to believe that any of the TV versions are winning.

      Kaley, you may hate the show, but even you can't deny that characters like Hershel, Shane, and Bob were done much better in the show. Don't be biased like that. :/

      First off, I don't hate the show. I just don't like what they've done with the series. Second, I was not specifically saying all comic characters were better. Hershel, Shane, and Bob are better in the show. You know me better than that, and everyone can guess that. :/

        Loading editor
    • SilentGlaive wrote:

      InsaneHippo wrote:

      SilentGlaive wrote:

      Gravelord wrote: How is TV Eugene almost beating comic Eugene? That makes no sense what-so-ever. Shane and Hershel are the only people I prefer in the TV Series, everyone else feels like lackluster versions.

      Hard to believe that any of the TV versions are winning.
      Kaley, you may hate the show, but even you can't deny that characters like Hershel, Shane, and Bob were done much better in the show. Don't be biased like that. :/
      First off, I don't hate the show. I just don't like what they've done with the series. Second, I was not specifically saying all comic characters were better. Hershel, Shane, and Bob are better in the show. You know me better than that, and everyone can guess that. :/

      You said it's hard to believe that any of the TV versions were winning, which implies that you mean all of them.

        Loading editor
    • Cheria wrote:
      InsaneHippo wrote:
      SilentGlaive wrote:

      Gravelord wrote: How is TV Eugene almost beating comic Eugene? That makes no sense what-so-ever. Shane and Hershel are the only people I prefer in the TV Series, everyone else feels like lackluster versions.

      Hard to believe that any of the TV versions are winning.
      Kaley, you may hate the show, but even you can't deny that characters like Hershel, Shane, and Bob were done much better in the show. Don't be biased like that. :/
      I agree with Hippo♫ And don't forget about Carol in the tv♪ She's much better than the comic version IMHO♪ The "Ben and Billy" arc in the tv is also better♪

      I like Comic Carol way more than TV Carol. She was very unpredictable, interesting, and realistic. It's how many of the weaker people would end up in an apocalypse. I also like the Ben and Billy arc more because it was out of nowhere, but still made sense and was realistically done.

        Loading editor
    • InsaneHippo wrote:

      SilentGlaive wrote:

      InsaneHippo wrote:

      SilentGlaive wrote:

      Gravelord wrote: How is TV Eugene almost beating comic Eugene? That makes no sense what-so-ever. Shane and Hershel are the only people I prefer in the TV Series, everyone else feels like lackluster versions.

      Hard to believe that any of the TV versions are winning.
      Kaley, you may hate the show, but even you can't deny that characters like Hershel, Shane, and Bob were done much better in the show. Don't be biased like that. :/
      First off, I don't hate the show. I just don't like what they've done with the series. Second, I was not specifically saying all comic characters were better. Hershel, Shane, and Bob are better in the show. You know me better than that, and everyone can guess that. :/

      You said it's hard to believe that any of the TV versions were winning, which implies that you mean all of them.

      Obviously not what I meant. I have already stated on several forums/blogs that I like TV Hershel and TV Shane over their comic counterparts. As well as chat.

        Loading editor
    • technically, rick and carl's story arc of getting over judiths death is still contnued in a very clever way in the tv series.

        Loading editor
    • Hey, how do you make the poll part there?

        Loading editor
    • OK, so I am here to aware you of that I just made a wiki called "Post-Apocolyptic Fan Fiction Wikia so if you want to make fan fiction for this show or any other Post-Apocolyptic genre's Search for Post-Apocolyptic Fan Fiction Wikia and create a story/TV Show/Movie

        Loading editor
    • Which was handled and ended better?
       
      191
       
      48
       

      The poll was created at 17:36 on April 13, 2015, and so far 239 people voted.
        Loading editor
    • Who is a more superior leader?
       
      76
       
      144
       
      39
       

      The poll was created at 17:36 on April 13, 2015, and so far 259 people voted.
        Loading editor
    • Who is more preferable?
       
      219
       
      21
       

      The poll was created at 17:40 on April 13, 2015, and so far 240 people voted.
        Loading editor
    • Which family was written better?
       
      42
       
      195
       

      The poll was created at 17:36 on April 13, 2015, and so far 237 people voted.
        Loading editor
    • InsaneHippo wrote:

      Cheria wrote:
      InsaneHippo wrote:
      SilentGlaive wrote:

      Gravelord wrote: How is TV Eugene almost beating comic Eugene? That makes no sense what-so-ever. Shane and Hershel are the only people I prefer in the TV Series, everyone else feels like lackluster versions.

      Hard to believe that any of the TV versions are winning.
      Kaley, you may hate the show, but even you can't deny that characters like Hershel, Shane, and Bob were done much better in the show. Don't be biased like that. :/
      I agree with Hippo♫ And don't forget about Carol in the tv♪ She's much better than the comic version IMHO♪ The "Ben and Billy" arc in the tv is also better♪

      I like Comic Carol way more than TV Carol. She was very unpredictable, interesting, and realistic. It's how many of the weaker people would end up in an apocalypse. I also like the Ben and Billy arc more because it was out of nowhere, but still made sense and was realistically done.

      I don't think it's fair to compare the two carols. They are basically two different characters. It's like comparing apples and oranges. they'd had two different stories and backgrounds that really only overlap at her name and Sophia. Also I don't think the comic ben and billy thing made sense. Until that arc I don't really remember ben showing any signs of him being sociopathic. Lizzie, throughout her appearances, show sign of her being unstable and mentally off (bonding with walker, melting down at her fathers death,ect) which lets us see the build up which I think makes for a much more realistic situation.

        Loading editor
    • Negan vs Gareth vs The Governor

        Loading editor
    • Eugene, why, he is a L-I-A-R, and the Governor is both an a$$ in The comics and TV series

        Loading editor
    • comic is superior to tv in every way. 

        Loading editor
    • Every TV main character doesn't live up to their comic counterpart. If Maggie takes lead of the Hilltop, then she'll be betterthan her comic part. 

        Loading editor
    • Colourful Walker wrote:
      Every TV main character doesn't live up to their comic counterpart. If Maggie takes lead of the Hilltop, then she'll be betterthan her comic part. 

      Really? Rosita, Gabriel, Morgan? All these characters are pretty much pushed to the background  in the comics. Hershel, Shane, Carol.... They are far more developed on TV. Bob.... Appears in two issues only and 13 episodes on TV. Aaron, Nicholas, Jessie.... These characters have way more screentime and are far more noticable. Gareth... although similar to Chris, he at least had some background.  And what's wrong with Glenn, Rick and Michonne? I agree Carl is too soft at the moment.

        Loading editor
    • Questlord195 wrote:
      Colourful Walker wrote:
      Every TV main character doesn't live up to their comic counterpart. If Maggie takes lead of the Hilltop, then she'll be betterthan her comic part. 
      Really? Rosita, Gabriel, Morgan? All these characters are pretty much pushed to the background  in the comics. Hershel, Shane, Carol.... They are far more developed on TV. Bob.... Appears in two issues only and 13 episodes on TV. Aaron, Nicholas, Jessie.... These characters have way more screentime and are far more noticable. Gareth... although similar to Chris, he at least had some background.  And what's wrong with Glenn, Rick and Michonne? I agree Carl is too soft at the moment.

      Rosita, fair enough, forgot about her.

      Gabriel, no, I prefer him when he has hardly any screentime. He's too irritating. Seth Gilliam is an ass too.

      Morgan. in my opinion, is annoying. He gives me a pain in my head, especially in Clear.


      Hershel was annoying until season 4.. Don't get me wrong, I like Scott Wilson, but TV Hershel was irritating..

      Shane. In TWD, there is room for one leader, and that is Rick. In season 2, it felt like Shane was the leader. And he was good, but I just prefer comics Shane.

      Carol. Okay. Honestly, I love both Carols. And I will admit now, TV Carol is .5% better. But I loved Carol when she was slowly going insane in the prison.


      Aaron, I like him equally.

      Nicholas. I hate him in the show with a passion. He is just a pathetic piece of crap.

      I forgot about Jessie. Her TV part is better.

      BOB? Woah woah, you mean, Bob the drunk who killed a man, dropped the supplies which could have resulted in Glenn and many, many other people's deaths? The man who has had more scrapes with death than anyone? The man who took a major death from the comic and used it himself? Bob is a mess. 

      Glenn, I preferred the optimist Glenn. TV Glenn is great though.

      This isn't TV show Michonne's fault, but I feel comic Michonne is more developed. This is because she's been around twice a long as TV Michonne, though. I love TV Michonne too, both are my favourites in their fields. If Richonne happens, she'll be better than her comic role.

      Rick? I think Andrew Lincoln is a phenominal actor, but "CORALLLLL" is a bit irritating. I like both Rick's equally, though.

        Loading editor
    • Colourful Walker wrote:
      Questlord195 wrote:
      Colourful Walker wrote:
      Every TV main character doesn't live up to their comic counterpart. If Maggie takes lead of the Hilltop, then she'll be betterthan her comic part. 
      Really? Rosita, Gabriel, Morgan? All these characters are pretty much pushed to the background  in the comics. Hershel, Shane, Carol.... They are far more developed on TV. Bob.... Appears in two issues only and 13 episodes on TV. Aaron, Nicholas, Jessie.... These characters have way more screentime and are far more noticable. Gareth... although similar to Chris, he at least had some background.  And what's wrong with Glenn, Rick and Michonne? I agree Carl is too soft at the moment.
      Rosita, fair enough, forgot about her.

      Gabriel, no, I prefer him when he has hardly any screentime. He's too irritating. Seth Gilliam is an ass too.

      Morgan. in my opinion, is annoying. He gives me a pain in my head, especially in Clear.


      Hershel was annoying until season 4.. Don't get me wrong, I like Scott Wilson, but TV Hershel was irritating..

      Shane. In TWD, there is room for one leader, and that is Rick. In season 2, it felt like Shane was the leader. And he was good, but I just prefer comics Shane.

      Carol. Okay. Honestly, I love both Carols. And I will admit now, TV Carol is .5% better. But I loved Carol when she was slowly going insane in the prison.


      Aaron, I like him equally.

      Nicholas. I hate him in the show with a passion. He is just a pathetic piece of crap.

      I forgot about Jessie. Her TV part is better.

      BOB? Woah woah, you mean, Bob the drunk who killed a man, dropped the supplies which could have resulted in Glenn and many, many other people's deaths? The man who has had more scrapes with death than anyone? The man who took a major death from the comic and used it himself? Bob is a mess. 

      Glenn, I preferred the optimist Glenn. TV Glenn is great though.

      This isn't TV show Michonne's fault, but I feel comic Michonne is more developed. This is because she's been around twice a long as TV Michonne, though. I love TV Michonne too, both are my favourites in their fields. If Richonne happens, she'll be better than her comic role.

      Rick? I think Andrew Lincoln is a phenominal actor, but "CORALLLLL" is a bit irritating. I like both Rick's equally, though.

      Oh, forgot the Hunters. I don't like the backstory. In the comics, The Hunters are a creepy, mysterious and cannibalistic group who kill a major character. In the show, they're not creepy or mysterious, and they kill an idiot.

        Loading editor
    • Colourful Walker wrote:
      Questlord195 wrote:
      Colourful Walker wrote:
      Every TV main character doesn't live up to their comic counterpart. If Maggie takes lead of the Hilltop, then she'll be betterthan her comic part. 
      Really? Rosita, Gabriel, Morgan? All these characters are pretty much pushed to the background  in the comics. Hershel, Shane, Carol.... They are far more developed on TV. Bob.... Appears in two issues only and 13 episodes on TV. Aaron, Nicholas, Jessie.... These characters have way more screentime and are far more noticable. Gareth... although similar to Chris, he at least had some background.  And what's wrong with Glenn, Rick and Michonne? I agree Carl is too soft at the moment.
      Rosita, fair enough, forgot about her.

      Gabriel, no, I prefer him when he has hardly any screentime. He's too irritating. Seth Gilliam is an ass too.

      Morgan. in my opinion, is annoying. He gives me a pain in my head, especially in Clear.


      Hershel was annoying until season 4.. Don't get me wrong, I like Scott Wilson, but TV Hershel was irritating..

      Shane. In TWD, there is room for one leader, and that is Rick. In season 2, it felt like Shane was the leader. And he was good, but I just prefer comics Shane.

      Carol. Okay. Honestly, I love both Carols. And I will admit now, TV Carol is .5% better. But I loved Carol when she was slowly going insane in the prison.


      Aaron, I like him equally.

      Nicholas. I hate him in the show with a passion. He is just a pathetic piece of crap.

      I forgot about Jessie. Her TV part is better.

      BOB? Woah woah, you mean, Bob the drunk who killed a man, dropped the supplies which could have resulted in Glenn and many, many other people's deaths? The man who has had more scrapes with death than anyone? The man who took a major death from the comic and used it himself? Bob is a mess. 

      Glenn, I preferred the optimist Glenn. TV Glenn is great though.

      This isn't TV show Michonne's fault, but I feel comic Michonne is more developed. This is because she's been around twice a long as TV Michonne, though. I love TV Michonne too, both are my favourites in their fields. If Richonne happens, she'll be better than her comic role.

      Rick? I think Andrew Lincoln is a phenominal actor, but "CORALLLLL" is a bit irritating. I like both Rick's equally, though.

      So we're not liking characters for being 'Irritating ?

      And lmao, I have to disagree 100% with Michonne not being as developed. Yes she may not be at the point where shes at in the comics but if we compare them to where they were now in both mediums I would say shes 100% excelled past her comic status, shes more human in a way instead of being a machine thats intended to kill walkers.

        Loading editor
    • In my Opinion:

      TV Characters that are Better than their Comic Counterparts:

      1. Morgan Jones I feel the late introduction can only benefit the character as he was sidelined in the comics.

      2. Hershel Greene - Probably one of my favourite characters in the TV Series due to how dramatic of a change they made w/ him due to Dale's absence.

      3. Shane Walsh - Compelling villain, likeable character and not over-used as some other villains.

      4. Carol Peleiter The change her character's been through, I tend to like the more dominant roles, probably thats why she's here.

      5. Rosita Espinosa Already, based upon the Season 6 trailer you can tell the dramatic difference the two counterparts have.

      6. Father Gabriel Stokes I feel the story alone will build up some sort of redemption arc, something he doesn't have a chance to do in the comics due to the vase amount of characters being sidelined and Killed Off-Panel these days. (Can I just add that we haven't seen CS Gabriel in almost 3-4 volumes?!?!)

      7. The Governor - Iconic villain, one that defines both mediums. However, giving him a motive is what pushes TV Governor further for me.

      8. Dale Horvath - I know his absence destroyed my favourite character Andrea, however his subtle exit kind of gave us Hershel and I have to admit, he still made a mark within his short time. Plus Comic Series Dale was just an asshole, something we had in Comic Series Hershel for a while.

      9. Bob Stookey -  When done right, we get characters like Bob. During his 13 episodes I was happy with the storyline he got, a fitting exit and a character that was just subtly placed into the show with so little material to go off on.

      10. Terminus/The Hunters - Overall backstory gave them more depth and purpose for me.

        Loading editor
    • Comic Characters that are better than their TV Series Counterpart:

      1. Andrea - Yes, I loved TV Series Andrea and I'll admit that, no shame in it at all. However, we all agree that CS Andrea is far superior. The reason being? She atleast did something that we love her for. I know we almost... ALMOST got her in S2 when she began practising but she got separated... something I dreaded so much because as soon as she ended up in Woodbury it was Game Over, TV Andrea has been ruined by Glenn Mazzara's disatorious reign and hatred towards the actress. However, lets all remember that our Hero, Andrea will remain through the Character of Sasha who I have contemplated renaming to Andrea since TV Andrea is virtually a different character entirely.

      2. Tyresse - I loved, yes I loved Tyresse in Season 3... Season 4A? Ok, I was warming up to him a little more but then 4B happened, destroying Tyresse's Character, the premiere to S5 which turned him into a child, atleast Tyresse in the Comic would beat the shit out of someone and went out nobaly? Not being bit by a goddamn child and sitting on his ass for 45 minutes as Noah ran for Michonne and Rick for what seemed like days? Sadly... Alas, another victim of Cash Whore Dixon.

      3. Abraham Ford - Sadly, I see him taking a similar fate to Tyresse in the TV Show. If Daryl Dixon survives Season 6 (Which he most likely will) I see Abraham's fate being only one option... Death. This is why Abraham Ford in the CS will always be Superior. In the CS, he has memorable moments, a welcoming relationship... In the TV Series we have "Mother Dick" "An Ocean of Shit"... Just these lines is all we'll have to remember him by because Cash Whore Dixon has stolen every moment that was rightfully owned by Abraham Ford.

      4. Carl Grimes - Tbh, the only thing holding me back from placing Carl in the other section is that he hasn't crossed the boarder from Good to Evil. Once he loses that eye, my god will I love the character. Evil Carl is everyones favourite Carl.

      5. Deanna/Douglas MonroeI felt the sudden change in gender wasn't needed, however Tovah's acting is still superb nontheless. However, I feel Douglas had more authority and dominance which allowed me to connect with his character more.


      Neutral Characters: (Love both Mediums respectively):

      1. Michonne

      2. Rick Grimes

      3. Maggie Greene

        Loading editor
    • QueenOfHearts2 wrote:
      Colourful Walker wrote:
      Questlord195 wrote:
      Colourful Walker wrote:
      Every TV main character doesn't live up to their comic counterpart. If Maggie takes lead of the Hilltop, then she'll be betterthan her comic part. 
      Really? Rosita, Gabriel, Morgan? All these characters are pretty much pushed to the background  in the comics. Hershel, Shane, Carol.... They are far more developed on TV. Bob.... Appears in two issues only and 13 episodes on TV. Aaron, Nicholas, Jessie.... These characters have way more screentime and are far more noticable. Gareth... although similar to Chris, he at least had some background.  And what's wrong with Glenn, Rick and Michonne? I agree Carl is too soft at the moment.
      Rosita, fair enough, forgot about her.

      Gabriel, no, I prefer him when he has hardly any screentime. He's too irritating. Seth Gilliam is an ass too.

      Morgan. in my opinion, is annoying. He gives me a pain in my head, especially in Clear.


      Hershel was annoying until season 4.. Don't get me wrong, I like Scott Wilson, but TV Hershel was irritating..

      Shane. In TWD, there is room for one leader, and that is Rick. In season 2, it felt like Shane was the leader. And he was good, but I just prefer comics Shane.

      Carol. Okay. Honestly, I love both Carols. And I will admit now, TV Carol is .5% better. But I loved Carol when she was slowly going insane in the prison.


      Aaron, I like him equally.

      Nicholas. I hate him in the show with a passion. He is just a pathetic piece of crap.

      I forgot about Jessie. Her TV part is better.

      BOB? Woah woah, you mean, Bob the drunk who killed a man, dropped the supplies which could have resulted in Glenn and many, many other people's deaths? The man who has had more scrapes with death than anyone? The man who took a major death from the comic and used it himself? Bob is a mess. 

      Glenn, I preferred the optimist Glenn. TV Glenn is great though.

      This isn't TV show Michonne's fault, but I feel comic Michonne is more developed. This is because she's been around twice a long as TV Michonne, though. I love TV Michonne too, both are my favourites in their fields. If Richonne happens, she'll be better than her comic role.

      Rick? I think Andrew Lincoln is a phenominal actor, but "CORALLLLL" is a bit irritating. I like both Rick's equally, though.

      So we're not liking characters for being 'Irritating ?

      And lmao, I have to disagree 100% with Michonne not being as developed. Yes she may not be at the point where shes at in the comics but if we compare them to where they were now in both mediums I would say shes 100% excelled past her comic status, shes more human in a way instead of being a machine thats intended to kill walkers.

      Well I'm not liking a character that's irritating. I don't know why anyone would. 

        Loading editor
    • Colourful Walker wrote:
      QueenOfHearts2 wrote:
      Colourful Walker wrote:
      Questlord195 wrote:
      Colourful Walker wrote:
      Every TV main character doesn't live up to their comic counterpart. If Maggie takes lead of the Hilltop, then she'll be betterthan her comic part. 
      Really? Rosita, Gabriel, Morgan? All these characters are pretty much pushed to the background  in the comics. Hershel, Shane, Carol.... They are far more developed on TV. Bob.... Appears in two issues only and 13 episodes on TV. Aaron, Nicholas, Jessie.... These characters have way more screentime and are far more noticable. Gareth... although similar to Chris, he at least had some background.  And what's wrong with Glenn, Rick and Michonne? I agree Carl is too soft at the moment.
      Rosita, fair enough, forgot about her.

      Gabriel, no, I prefer him when he has hardly any screentime. He's too irritating. Seth Gilliam is an ass too.

      Morgan. in my opinion, is annoying. He gives me a pain in my head, especially in Clear.


      Hershel was annoying until season 4.. Don't get me wrong, I like Scott Wilson, but TV Hershel was irritating..

      Shane. In TWD, there is room for one leader, and that is Rick. In season 2, it felt like Shane was the leader. And he was good, but I just prefer comics Shane.

      Carol. Okay. Honestly, I love both Carols. And I will admit now, TV Carol is .5% better. But I loved Carol when she was slowly going insane in the prison.


      Aaron, I like him equally.

      Nicholas. I hate him in the show with a passion. He is just a pathetic piece of crap.

      I forgot about Jessie. Her TV part is better.

      BOB? Woah woah, you mean, Bob the drunk who killed a man, dropped the supplies which could have resulted in Glenn and many, many other people's deaths? The man who has had more scrapes with death than anyone? The man who took a major death from the comic and used it himself? Bob is a mess. 

      Glenn, I preferred the optimist Glenn. TV Glenn is great though.

      This isn't TV show Michonne's fault, but I feel comic Michonne is more developed. This is because she's been around twice a long as TV Michonne, though. I love TV Michonne too, both are my favourites in their fields. If Richonne happens, she'll be better than her comic role.

      Rick? I think Andrew Lincoln is a phenominal actor, but "CORALLLLL" is a bit irritating. I like both Rick's equally, though.

      So we're not liking characters for being 'Irritating ?

      And lmao, I have to disagree 100% with Michonne not being as developed. Yes she may not be at the point where shes at in the comics but if we compare them to where they were now in both mediums I would say shes 100% excelled past her comic status, shes more human in a way instead of being a machine thats intended to kill walkers.

      Well I'm not liking a character that's irritating. I don't know why anyone would. 

      I don't understand how a character can be 'Irritating'. Some do make weird choices yes but thats part of their character, I dont see how any of them can be seen in this way.

        Loading editor
    • Dylanloganfaith2000
      Dylanloganfaith2000 removed this reply because:
      I'm removing because I'm gonna write a different post.
      12:26, May 7, 2018
      This reply has been removed
    • The one character I'm definetely sure I prefer from the comics is Lori. I mean, sure, she was a hot-headed bitch at times, but she was also a caring mother and wife, and a responsible one at that. She still made decisions that were for the group's sake, and, oh yeah, she never let Carl out of her sight! She actually deserved living a bit longer than her TV counterpart.

      Also, nothing against her actress, I'm sure she's a nice person, but something about her just bugs me.

        Loading editor
    • I think what bugs you is a reminder that she played Lori, I agree with the haters, she was such a bitch, no doubt Sarah Wayne Callies is a great actress, have you seen Colony on USA

        Loading editor
    • NikkiNicks wrote:
      I think what bugs you is a reminder that she played Lori, I agree with the haters, she was such a bitch, no doubt Sarah Wayne Callies is a great actress, have you seen Colony on USA

      No, no, I meant that there is just something about the actress' appearance that bugs me. Subliminally. I have no idea what, though.

        Loading editor
    • imho, the biggest detrement to the comics is at most times, it just feels like the rick and carl show, which i mean if the comic is made to primarily focus around 2 characters than fine, go for it, but when you make a comic thats only seems like it wants to be focused on 2 characters but then adds in 40+ other characters who don't get nearly enough development because the story is almost always centered around 2 characters, so you almost never get more personal scenes with secondary characters wich usually means they get underdeveloped only to get killed, character development and overall storytelling is what generally puts tv characters in the limelight compared to their comic versions for me, and while yes, cases may prove different (allen,lori,axel etc.) characters like abraham for example in the comic always felt like a trope, like big gruff military man whos there to be the groups muscle, and ocassionally have little sprinkles of characters development and backstory, we didn't really get the backstory and development and defined personality of the tv version. and as for the 2 characters, while they're pretty neck and neck tv show ricks little niches and quirks and andrew licolns performance pushes him over the edge for me, but with carl its pretty neutral for the point in the story.


      but hey thats just my long drawn out opinion

        Loading editor
    • FightTheDead118. wrote:
      imho, the biggest detrement to the comics is at most times, it just feels like the rick and carl show, which i mean if the comic is made to primarily focus around 2 characters than fine, go for it, but when you make a comic thats only seems like it wants to be focused on 2 characters but then adds in 40+ other characters who don't get nearly enough development because the story is almost always centered around 2 characters, so you almost never get more personal scenes with secondary characters wich usually means they get underdeveloped only to get killed, character development and overall storytelling is what generally puts tv characters in the limelight compared to their comic versions for me, and while yes, cases may prove different (allen,lori,axel etc.) characters like abraham for example in the comic always felt like a trope, like big gruff military man whos there to be the groups muscle, and ocassionally have little sprinkles of characters development and backstory, we didn't really get the backstory and development and defined personality of the tv version. and as for the 2 characters, while they're pretty neck and neck tv show ricks little niches and quirks and andrew licolns performance pushes him over the edge for me, but with carl its pretty neutral for the point in the story.


      but hey thats just my long drawn out opinion

      Well it's realistic that there are people you don't see all the time, because there are a lot of characters, and the comic is mainly about Rick and Carls family and relationship.

        Loading editor
    • Guy Underscore23 wrote:
      Which family was written better?
       
      42
       
      195
       

      The poll was created at 17:36 on April 13, 2015, and so far 237 people voted.

      I mean, this is kinda hard to judge, because Jessie is astonishing in the show, but Ron idk who to compare him to Ron or Sam.

        Loading editor
    • Why make a poll for Lilly? She cant be compared to a counter part, she has two, April Chalmers and Lilly Caul

        Loading editor
    • Bob and Lilly are amazing in the comic universe, but only if you read the novels.

        Loading editor
    • I'M BACK WITH SOME MORE ITS BEEN YEARS DAMN. Some of these comic characters just got introduced so it may be too early to tell but you can always come back and change your answer.

      Which Negan do you like better?
       
      80
       
      31
       
      2
       

      The poll was created at 03:39 on November 23, 2016, and so far 113 people voted.
      Which Jesus do you like better?
       
      79
       
      30
       
      1
       

      The poll was created at 03:39 on November 23, 2016, and so far 110 people voted.
      Which Aaron do you like better?
       
      15
       
      87
       
      1
       

      The poll was created at 03:41 on November 23, 2016, and so far 103 people voted.
      Which Father Gabriel do you like better?
       
      7
       
      92
       
      6
       

      The poll was created at 03:39 on November 23, 2016, and so far 105 people voted.
      Which Ezekiel do you like better?
       
      43
       
      62
       
      2
       

      The poll was created at 03:41 on November 23, 2016, and so far 107 people voted.
      Which Dwight do you like better?
       
      74
       
      20
       
      9
       

      The poll was created at 03:41 on November 23, 2016, and so far 103 people voted.
      Which Sherry do you like better?
       
      9
       
      76
       
      14
       

      The poll was created at 03:50 on November 23, 2016, and so far 99 people voted.
      Which Gregory do you like better?
       
      12
       
      63
       
      27
       

      The poll was created at 03:50 on November 23, 2016, and so far 102 people voted.
      Which Spencer Monroe do you like better?
       
      12
       
      71
       
      20
       

      The poll was created at 03:41 on November 23, 2016, and so far 103 people voted.
      Which Former Alexandria Leader do you like better?
       
      22
       
      72
       
      5
       

      The poll was created at 03:45 on November 23, 2016, and so far 99 people voted.
      Which Anderson Family do you like better?
       
      7
       
      69
       
      8
       

      The poll was created at 03:45 on November 23, 2016, and so far 84 people voted.
      Which Denise do you like better?
       
      60
       
      41
       
      3
       

      The poll was created at 03:50 on November 23, 2016, and so far 104 people voted.
      Which Benjamin do you like better?
       
      1
       
      80
       
      7
       

      The poll was created at 03:50 on November 23, 2016, and so far 88 people voted.
      Which Nicholas do you like better?
       
      65
       
      15
       
      7
       

      The poll was created at 03:50 on November 23, 2016, and so far 87 people voted.
      Which Heath do you like better?
       
      79
       
      15
       
      3
       

      The poll was created at 03:41 on November 23, 2016, and so far 97 people voted.
        Loading editor
    • Most of the Comic characters are ALOT better, mainly because the Show ruined characters (Denise, Nicholas, Tyreese, Carol, Heath, Dwight, etc.)

        Loading editor
    • How are Dwight, Heath and Carol ruined?

        Loading editor
    • ZukeTheDuke wrote: Most of the Comic characters are ALOT better, mainly because the Show ruined characters (Denise, Nicholas, Tyreese, Carol, Heath, Dwight, etc.)

      Carol, Dwight, Nicholas and Heath ruined? Carol is much better, we've barely seen Heath, Dwight's been great and Nicholas was a nice different feature on the show..

        Loading editor
    • Kovarro wrote:

      ZukeTheDuke wrote: Most of the Comic characters are ALOT better, mainly because the Show ruined characters (Denise, Nicholas, Tyreese, Carol, Heath, Dwight, etc.)

      Carol, Dwight, Nicholas and Heath ruined? Carol is much better, we've barely seen Heath, Dwight's been great and Nicholas was a nice different feature on the show..

      They just made Carol an over the top, badass, unrealistic character who I just don't like. I'd rather have the mentally insane Carol from the Comics.

      Dwight was more ruined on the introduction side, the episode when he first appeared was really boring to me, because alot of it seems to be just flat out weird.

      Nicholas was just extremely ruined. First off, they gave the rebellious side of Nicholas to Carter, and his good side isn't even shown in the TV. He's a coward, and simply a burden to the group. In the Comic, his rebellion made more sense because he was more involved; Carter only appeared in episode. It's also really nice to see Nicholas sacrificing himself for Rick during All Out War, also having a memorable and sad death. But no, in the TV he just shoots himself. Yeah, Glenn and Nick were gonna die anyway, but c'mon.

      I can't blame Heath for being bad, because the actor didn't sign a contract to become a main character, because of his other TV show/movies that are in the works. I do like Heath, but he just doesn't have enough screentime which sucks. But again, I can't blame the guy.

        Loading editor
    • Almost everyone from the comics is better than the TV, also TV Maggie is overrated.

        Loading editor
    • ALinkToThePasta wrote:
      Almost everyone from the comics is better than the TV, also TV Maggie is overrated.

      Finally someone who has the same ideas...

        Loading editor
    • TV Maggie is the same as Comic Maggie and having Carol be a badass is best change the TV series has ever made.

        Loading editor
    • ALinkToThePasta wrote: Almost everyone from the comics is better than the TV, also TV Maggie is overrated.

      Morgan, Shane, The Hunters, Glenn? Bias to the end hey

        Loading editor
    • Kovarro wrote:

      ALinkToThePasta wrote: Almost everyone from the comics is better than the TV, also TV Maggie is overrated.

      Morgan, Shane, The Hunters, Glenn? Bias to the end hey

      Don't forget The Marauders, The Scavengers, Benjamin, Father Gabriel, Bob, Michonne, Rosita and the Anderson Family

        Loading editor
    • Wwefan2 wrote:

      Kovarro wrote:

      ALinkToThePasta wrote: Almost everyone from the comics is better than the TV, also TV Maggie is overrated.

      Morgan, Shane, The Hunters, Glenn? Bias to the end hey

      Don't forget The Marauders, The Scavengers, Benjamin, Father Gabriel, Bob, Michonne, Rosita and the Anderson Family

      Very true, I mean I get people can have opinions, but there are just some characters that are obviously better depicted in the show.

        Loading editor
    • Kovarro wrote:

      ALinkToThePasta wrote: Almost everyone from the comics is better than the TV, also TV Maggie is overrated.

      Morgan, Shane, The Hunters, Glenn? Bias to the end hey

      Never said all comic characters are better Kovarroboi, and Glenn sucks in everything. 

      I like Joe and Gareth and all the other guys but most comic characters are much better than the TV ones.

        Loading editor
    • ALinkToThePasta wrote:

      Kovarro wrote:

      ALinkToThePasta wrote: Almost everyone from the comics is better than the TV, also TV Maggie is overrated.

      Morgan, Shane, The Hunters, Glenn? Bias to the end hey

      Never said all comic characters are better Kovarroboi, and Glenn sucks in everything. 

      I like Joe and Gareth and all the other guys but most comic characters are much better than the TV ones.

      Well you did say almost everyone from the comic character is better, so that could easily be taken out of context. Plus, Glenn is more badass in the TV show and TV Maggie is the same as Comic Maggie.

        Loading editor
    • Personally, I think Ben and Billy's story-arc is much better handled. I mean, think about it. They see both their mother AND father die.  Get attacked by herds and go through the trauma of The Governor. But, it's all so subtle (Up until the cat scene). Ben is seen to be somewhat more violent in the background. (Chasing Billy, waving around sticks etc.) Whereas in the TV Show, it was so obvious that Lizzie was going to kill Mika. There was an entire episode dedicated to her psychotic nature.

        Loading editor
    • IMO, Ben's psychopathic nature just came out of no where, for Lizzie there was build up for it.

        Loading editor
    • Dylanloganfaith2000 wrote:
      • Andrea Harrison - Comics
      • Amy Harrison - TV

      Is their last name really Harrison? What is the source for this?

        Loading editor
    • Siirlock wrote:

      Dylanloganfaith2000 wrote:
      • Andrea Harrison - Comics
      • Amy Harrison - TV

      Is their last name really Harrison? What is the source for this?

      In TWD Survival Instincts, you meet Andrea and Amy's father who's name is Terry Harrison

        Loading editor
    • Wwefan2 wrote:
      In TWD Survival Instincts, you meet Andrea and Amy's father who's name is Terry Harrison

      Thanks for the info. So...is this considered canon, or not? In "Tell It To The Frogs", the sisters' conversation while fishing implied that their parents were in Florida.

        Loading editor
    • Siirlock wrote:

      Wwefan2 wrote:
      In TWD Survival Instincts, you meet Andrea and Amy's father who's name is Terry Harrison

      Thanks for the info. So...is this considered canon, or not? In "Tell It To The Frogs", the sisters' conversation while fishing implied that their parents were in Florida.

      Yes, Survival Instincts is canon, it tells the backstory of Daryl during his first days in the apocalypse.

        Loading editor
    • Pretty much what I think is better: Rick Grimes - TV

      Carl Grimes - TV

      Lori Grimes - TV

      Shane Walsh - TV

      Dale Horvath - TV

      Glenn Rhee - TV

      Andrea - TV

      Carol Peletier - TV

      Morgan Jones - TV

      Maggie Greene - TV

      Hershel Greene - TV

      Billy Greene/Beth Greene - Beth Greene

      Michonne - TV

      The Governor - TV

      Tyreese - TV

      Bob Stookey - TV

      Abraham Ford - TV

      Eugene Porter - TV

      Rosita Espinosa - TV

      Gabriel Stokes - TV

      Aaron - TV

      Spencer Monroe - TV

      Douglas Monroe/Deanna Monroe - Deanna Monroe

      Anderson Family - TV

      Negan - TV

      Dwight - TV

      Paul "Jesus" Monroe/Rovia - TV

      Gregory - TV

      Ezekiel - TV

      Shiva - TV

      Etc.

      Pretty much the TV Characters are better than the Comic Versions.

        Loading editor
    • Mitt Campbell wrote:
      Pretty much what I think is better:

      Rick Grimes - TV

      Carl Grimes - TV

      Lori Grimes - TV

      Shane Walsh - TV

      Dale Horvath - TV

      Glenn Rhee - TV

      Andrea - TV

      Carol Peletier - TV

      Morgan Jones - TV

      Maggie Greene - TV

      Hershel Greene - TV

      Billy Greene/Beth Greene - Beth Greene

      Michonne - TV

      The Governor - TV

      Tyreese - TV

      Bob Stookey - TV

      Abraham Ford - TV

      Eugene Porter - TV

      Rosita Espinosa - TV

      Gabriel Stokes - TV

      Aaron - TV

      Spencer Monroe - TV

      Douglas Monroe/Deanna Monroe - Deanna Monroe

      Anderson Family - TV

      Negan - TV

      Dwight - TV

      Paul "Jesus" Monroe/Rovia - TV

      Gregory - TV

      Ezekiel - TV

      Shiva - TV

      Etc.

      Pretty much the TV Characters are better than the Comic Versions.

      You haven't even read the comics lmao, once you'll read it you'll learn that the comics are way better and have a better and deeper meaning than the show, which is made for "causuals" like you.

        Loading editor
    • ZukeTheDuke wrote:

      Mitt Campbell wrote:
      Pretty much what I think is better:

      Rick Grimes - TV

      Carl Grimes - TV

      Lori Grimes - TV

      Shane Walsh - TV

      Dale Horvath - TV

      Glenn Rhee - TV

      Andrea - TV

      Carol Peletier - TV

      Morgan Jones - TV

      Maggie Greene - TV

      Hershel Greene - TV

      Billy Greene/Beth Greene - Beth Greene

      Michonne - TV

      The Governor - TV

      Tyreese - TV

      Bob Stookey - TV

      Abraham Ford - TV

      Eugene Porter - TV

      Rosita Espinosa - TV

      Gabriel Stokes - TV

      Aaron - TV

      Spencer Monroe - TV

      Douglas Monroe/Deanna Monroe - Deanna Monroe

      Anderson Family - TV

      Negan - TV

      Dwight - TV

      Paul "Jesus" Monroe/Rovia - TV

      Gregory - TV

      Ezekiel - TV

      Shiva - TV

      Etc.

      Pretty much the TV Characters are better than the Comic Versions.

      You haven't even read the comics lmao, once you'll read it you'll learn that the comics are way better and have a better and deeper meaning than the show, which is made for "causuals" like you.

      I beg your pardon.

        Loading editor
    • Mitt Campbell wrote:

      ZukeTheDuke wrote:

      Mitt Campbell wrote:
      Pretty much what I think is better:

      Rick Grimes - TV

      Carl Grimes - TV

      Lori Grimes - TV

      Shane Walsh - TV

      Dale Horvath - TV

      Glenn Rhee - TV

      Andrea - TV

      Carol Peletier - TV

      Morgan Jones - TV

      Maggie Greene - TV

      Hershel Greene - TV

      Billy Greene/Beth Greene - Beth Greene

      Michonne - TV

      The Governor - TV

      Tyreese - TV

      Bob Stookey - TV

      Abraham Ford - TV

      Eugene Porter - TV

      Rosita Espinosa - TV

      Gabriel Stokes - TV

      Aaron - TV

      Spencer Monroe - TV

      Douglas Monroe/Deanna Monroe - Deanna Monroe

      Anderson Family - TV

      Negan - TV

      Dwight - TV

      Paul "Jesus" Monroe/Rovia - TV

      Gregory - TV

      Ezekiel - TV

      Shiva - TV

      Etc.

      Pretty much the TV Characters are better than the Comic Versions.

      You haven't even read the comics lmao, once you'll read it you'll learn that the comics are way better and have a better and deeper meaning than the show, which is made for "causuals" like you.

      I beg your pardon.

      you can't say the TV characters are better than the Comic characters when you haven't even read the comics.

        Loading editor
    • Oooh, and the heat is on! Somebody pass the popcorn!

        Loading editor
    • PowerPiranha666 wrote:
      Oooh, and the heat is on! Somebody pass the popcorn!
      • hands over popcorn* I'm putting on my #1 Savage crown, ready to oblitirate everyone who puts up an argument with me related to comic discussions.

      (if you can't detect sarcasm, then here's a quick message to say that this is a joke if somehow someone gets triggered.)

        Loading editor
    • Mitt Campbell wrote:
      Pretty much what I think is better:

      Rick Grimes - TV

      Carl Grimes - TV

      Lori Grimes - TV

      Shane Walsh - TV

      Dale Horvath - TV

      Glenn Rhee - TV

      Andrea - TV

      Carol Peletier - TV

      Morgan Jones - TV

      Maggie Greene - TV

      Hershel Greene - TV

      Billy Greene/Beth Greene - Beth Greene

      Michonne - TV

      The Governor - TV

      Tyreese - TV

      Bob Stookey - TV

      Abraham Ford - TV

      Eugene Porter - TV

      Rosita Espinosa - TV

      Gabriel Stokes - TV

      Aaron - TV

      Spencer Monroe - TV

      Douglas Monroe/Deanna Monroe - Deanna Monroe

      Anderson Family - TV

      Negan - TV

      Dwight - TV

      Paul "Jesus" Monroe/Rovia - TV

      Gregory - TV

      Ezekiel - TV

      Shiva - TV

      Etc.

      Pretty much the TV Characters are better than the Comic Versions.

      "Andrea - TV"

      just let that sink in for a while...

      just...

      this is slowly turning my brain into paste

      like

      i can't even right now

      like, i'm of course losing brain cells because of the other things in that one comment but just...

      that one tiny part is killing me

        Loading editor
    • The Boomerang wrote:

      Mitt Campbell wrote:
      Pretty much what I think is better:

      Rick Grimes - TV

      Carl Grimes - TV

      Lori Grimes - TV

      Shane Walsh - TV

      Dale Horvath - TV

      Glenn Rhee - TV

      Andrea - TV

      Carol Peletier - TV

      Morgan Jones - TV

      Maggie Greene - TV

      Hershel Greene - TV

      Billy Greene/Beth Greene - Beth Greene

      Michonne - TV

      The Governor - TV

      Tyreese - TV

      Bob Stookey - TV

      Abraham Ford - TV

      Eugene Porter - TV

      Rosita Espinosa - TV

      Gabriel Stokes - TV

      Aaron - TV

      Spencer Monroe - TV

      Douglas Monroe/Deanna Monroe - Deanna Monroe

      Anderson Family - TV

      Negan - TV

      Dwight - TV

      Paul "Jesus" Monroe/Rovia - TV

      Gregory - TV

      Ezekiel - TV

      Shiva - TV

      Etc.

      Pretty much the TV Characters are better than the Comic Versions.

      "Andrea - TV"

      just let that sink in for a while...

      just...

      this is slowly turning my brain into paste

      like

      i can't even right now

      like, i'm of course losing brain cells because of the other things in that one comment but just...

      that one tiny part is killing me

      Well too bad for you.

        Loading editor
    • Rick - TV

      Carl - Comics

      Lori - Comics

      Andrea - Comics

      Maggie - TV

      Glenn - TV

      Dale - Comics

      Shane - TV

      Tyreese - TV

      Hershel - TV

      Morgan - TV

      Carol - TV

      Michonne - TV

      The Governor - TV

      Bob - TV

      Abraham - TV

      Eugene - Comics

      Rosita - TV

      Martinez - TV

      Axel - Comics

      Jim - TV

      Amy - TV

      Lilly - Comics

      Sophia - Comics

      Otis - TV

      Patricia - Comics

      Ben/Billy, Lizzie Mika - Lizzie and Mika (TV)

      The Marauders/The Claimers - The Claimers (TV)

      Final Prison Battle - Comics

      Rick's hand - Cut it off (Comics)

      Judith's status - Alive (TV)

      Terminus/Hunters - Terminus (TV)

      Douglas/Deanna - Deanna (TV)

      Nicholas - Comics

      Anderson Family - TV

      Negan - Comics

      Jesus - Comics

      Aaron - TV

      Gabriel - TV

      Dwight - TV

      Sherry - TV

      Gregory - TV

      Spencer - TV

      Denise - TV

      Heath - Comics

      Benjamin - TV

        Loading editor
    • Wwefan2 wrote:
      Rick - TV

      Carl - Comics

      Lori - Comics

      Andrea - Comics

      Maggie - TV

      Glenn - TV

      Dale - Comics

      Shane - TV

      Tyreese - TV

      Hershel - TV

      Morgan - TV

      Carol - TV

      Michonne - TV

      The Governor - TV

      Bob - TV

      Abraham - TV

      Eugene - Comics

      Rosita - TV

      Martinez - TV

      Axel - Comics

      Jim - TV

      Amy - TV

      Lilly - Comics

      Sophia - Comics

      Otis - TV

      Patricia - Comics

      Ben/Billy, Lizzie Mika - Lizzie and Mika (TV)

      The Marauders/The Claimers - The Claimers (TV)

      Final Prison Battle - Comics

      Rick's hand - Cut it off (Comics)

      Judith's status - Alive (TV)

      Terminus/Hunters - Terminus (TV)

      Douglas/Deanna - Deanna (TV)

      Nicholas - Comics

      Anderson Family - TV

      Negan - Comics

      Jesus - Comics

      Aaron - TV

      Gabriel - TV

      Dwight - TV

      Sherry - TV

      Gregory - TV

      Spencer - TV

      Denise - TV

      Heath - Comics

      Benjamin - TV

      Rick, Tyreese, Hershel, Governor, Otis, Terminus, Alexandria leadership, Dwight and Denise better in the TV? wtf

        Loading editor
    • ZukeTheDuke wrote:

      Wwefan2 wrote:
      Rick - TV

      Carl - Comics

      Lori - Comics

      Andrea - Comics

      Maggie - TV

      Glenn - TV

      Dale - Comics

      Shane - TV

      Tyreese - TV

      Hershel - TV

      Morgan - TV

      Carol - TV

      Michonne - TV

      The Governor - TV

      Bob - TV

      Abraham - TV

      Eugene - Comics

      Rosita - TV

      Martinez - TV

      Axel - Comics

      Jim - TV

      Amy - TV

      Lilly - Comics

      Sophia - Comics

      Otis - TV

      Patricia - Comics

      Ben/Billy, Lizzie Mika - Lizzie and Mika (TV)

      The Marauders/The Claimers - The Claimers (TV)

      Final Prison Battle - Comics

      Rick's hand - Cut it off (Comics)

      Judith's status - Alive (TV)

      Terminus/Hunters - Terminus (TV)

      Douglas/Deanna - Deanna (TV)

      Nicholas - Comics

      Anderson Family - TV

      Negan - Comics

      Jesus - Comics

      Aaron - TV

      Gabriel - TV

      Dwight - TV

      Sherry - TV

      Gregory - TV

      Spencer - TV

      Denise - TV

      Heath - Comics

      Benjamin - TV

      Rick, Tyreese, Hershel, Governor, Otis, Terminus, Alexandria leadership, Dwight and Denise better in the TV? wtf

      It's my opinion.

        Loading editor
    • Wwefan2 wrote:

      ZukeTheDuke wrote:

      Wwefan2 wrote:
      Rick - TV

      Carl - Comics

      Lori - Comics

      Andrea - Comics

      Maggie - TV

      Glenn - TV

      Dale - Comics

      Shane - TV

      Tyreese - TV

      Hershel - TV

      Morgan - TV

      Carol - TV

      Michonne - TV

      The Governor - TV

      Bob - TV

      Abraham - TV

      Eugene - Comics

      Rosita - TV

      Martinez - TV

      Axel - Comics

      Jim - TV

      Amy - TV

      Lilly - Comics

      Sophia - Comics

      Otis - TV

      Patricia - Comics

      Ben/Billy, Lizzie Mika - Lizzie and Mika (TV)

      The Marauders/The Claimers - The Claimers (TV)

      Final Prison Battle - Comics

      Rick's hand - Cut it off (Comics)

      Judith's status - Alive (TV)

      Terminus/Hunters - Terminus (TV)

      Douglas/Deanna - Deanna (TV)

      Nicholas - Comics

      Anderson Family - TV

      Negan - Comics

      Jesus - Comics

      Aaron - TV

      Gabriel - TV

      Dwight - TV

      Sherry - TV

      Gregory - TV

      Spencer - TV

      Denise - TV

      Heath - Comics

      Benjamin - TV

      Rick, Tyreese, Hershel, Governor, Otis, Terminus, Alexandria leadership, Dwight and Denise better in the TV? wtf

      It's my opinion.

      Yes.

        Loading editor
    • InsaneHippo wrote:
      SilentGlaive wrote:

      Gravelord wrote: How is TV Eugene almost beating comic Eugene? That makes no sense what-so-ever. Shane and Hershel are the only people I prefer in the TV Series, everyone else feels like lackluster versions.

      Hard to believe that any of the TV versions are winning.
      Kaley, you may hate the show, but even you can't deny that characters like Hershel, Shane, and Bob were done much better in the show. Don't be biased like that. :/

      InsaneCringe

        Loading editor
    • CamTheWoot
      CamTheWoot removed this reply because:
      wtf
      17:17, February 13, 2017
      This reply has been removed
    • CamTheWoot
      CamTheWoot removed this reply because:
      damn't
      17:17, February 13, 2017
      This reply has been removed
    • Hahah, holy shit, I've never seen this thread before. Brb, hanging myself

        Loading editor
    • Oh this'll be fun, ok, my list:

      Rick - TV

      Carl - Neither

      Lori - Comics

      Andrea - Comics

      Maggie - TV

      Glenn - TV

      Dale - Comics

      Shane - TV

      Tyreese - Comics

      Hershel - TV

      Morgan - Neither

      Carol - Comics

      Michonne - TV

      The Governor - TV

      Bob - TV

      Abraham - Comics

      Eugene - Comics

      Rosita - Neither

      Martinez - TV

      Axel - Comics

      Jim - TV

      Amy - TV

      Lilly - Comics

      Sophia - Comics

      Otis - TV

      Patricia - Comics

      Douglas/Deanna - Douglas (Comics)

      Nicholas - Comics

      Negan - Comics

      Jesus - TV

      Aaron - TV

      Gabriel - TV

      Dwight - Comic

      Sherry - Neither

      Gregory - TV

      Spencer - Comics

      Denise - Comics

      Heath - Neither

        Loading editor
    • Rick: Show

      Shane: Show

      Lori: Neither

      Carl: Comics

      Morgan: Show

      Dale: Comics

      Glenn: Show

      Andrea: Comics

      Carol: Show

      Maggie: Show

      Hershel: Show

      Beth/Billy : Billy (Comics)

      Michonne: Show

      The Governor: Both

      Tyreese: Comics

      Bob: Show

      Tara Chambler/Tara Chalmers: Neither

      Abraham: Both

      Rosita: Show

      Eugene: Comics

      Gareth/Chris: Gareth (Show)

      Gabriel: Show

      Aaron: Show

      Deanna/Douglas: Both

      Jessie: Show

      Spencer: Neither

      Dwight: Both

      Jesus: Comics

      Gregory: Neither

      Negan: Both

      Ezekiel: Show

      Generally speaking I like Show characters more than the Comics characters (with the only exceptions: Andrea, Dale, Carl, Tyreese, Eugene and Jesus).  Anyway, just remember that this is MY personal opinion.

        Loading editor
    • Can someone please do a poll that is the walking dead comic vs tv show which is better

        Loading editor
    • Bruh it's Trevor wrote: Can someone please do a poll that is the walking dead comic vs tv show which is better

      Why?

        Loading editor
    • I just wanna know other people's opinions

        Loading editor
    • Bruh it's Trevor wrote: Can someone please do a poll that is the walking dead comic vs tv show which is better

      There's already a poll on the main page between the show, game, comic, and FTWD.

        Loading editor
    • Oh link please thanks

        Loading editor
    • Bruh it's Trevor wrote: Oh link please thanks

      Just click the big "The Walking Dead Wiki" logo in the top left corner and scroll down a little.

        Loading editor
    • Dear the 43 people who voted for the TV version of Andrea.

      Please die a slow and painful death, you deserve it for how wrong you are

        Loading editor
    • Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Dear the 43 people who voted for the TV version of Andrea.

      Please die a slow and painful death, you deserve it for how wrong you are


      How old are you?

        Loading editor
    • Siirlock wrote:

      Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Dear the 43 people who voted for the TV version of Andrea.

      Please die a slow and painful death, you deserve it for how wrong you are


      How old are you?

      Why does age matter

        Loading editor
    • CytroGhost01 wrote:

      Siirlock wrote:

      Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Dear the 43 people who voted for the TV version of Andrea.

      Please die a slow and painful death, you deserve it for how wrong you are


      How old are you?

      Why does age matter?

        Loading editor
    • CytroGhost01 wrote:

      Siirlock wrote:

      Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Dear the 43 people who voted for the TV version of Andrea.

      Please die a slow and painful death, you deserve it for how wrong you are


      How old are you?
      Why does age matter

      It was a rhetorical question.

        Loading editor
    • Siirlock wrote:
      CytroGhost01 wrote:

      Siirlock wrote:


      Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Dear the 43 people who voted for the TV version of Andrea.

      Please die a slow and painful death, you deserve it for how wrong you are


      How old are you?
      Why does age matter
      It was a rhetorical question.

      I love rhetorical questions, maybe somebody will ask me one someday.

        Loading editor
    • Siirlock wrote:
      Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Dear the 43 people who voted for the TV version of Andrea.

      Please die a slow and painful death, you deserve it for how wrong you are


      How old are you?

      Not sure why you're asking me that

        Loading editor
    • Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Siirlock wrote:
      Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Dear the 43 people who voted for the TV version of Andrea.

      Please die a slow and painful death, you deserve it for how wrong you are


      How old are you?
      Not sure why you're asking me that

      Children on the internet are generally perceived as being more dramatic and taking trivial things like online debates too seriously to the point of making death threats (i.e. "Please die a slow and painful death").

      Not trying to get involved in the discussion, just providing a useless explanation.

        Loading editor
    • PowerPiranha666 wrote:
      Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Siirlock wrote:
      Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Dear the 43 people who voted for the TV version of Andrea.

      Please die a slow and painful death, you deserve it for how wrong you are

      How old are you?
      Not sure why you're asking me that
      Children on the internet are generally perceived as being more dramatic and taking trivial things like online debates too seriously to the point of making death threats (i.e. "Please die a slow and painful death").

      Yeah, that.

        Loading editor
    • They voted TV cause they didn't read the Comics, not because they prefer the TV counterpart. 

        Loading editor
    • DipsonDP wrote:
      They voted TV cause they didn't read the Comics, not because they prefer the TV counterpart. 

      I don't know, is there anything likeable about Comic Carol?

        Loading editor
    • lol no.

        Loading editor
    • Siirlock wrote:
      PowerPiranha666 wrote:
      Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Siirlock wrote:
      Creeper man1001 wrote:
      Dear the 43 people who voted for the TV version of Andrea.

      Please die a slow and painful death, you deserve it for how wrong you are

      How old are you?
      Not sure why you're asking me that
      Children on the internet are generally perceived as being more dramatic and taking trivial things like online debates too seriously to the point of making death threats (i.e. "Please die a slow and painful death").
      Yeah, that.

      Makes sense I suppose. I'm not a child, but I find that to be a suitable punishment for someone choosing TV Andrea over comic Andrea

        Loading editor
    • Kind of depressing.

        Loading editor
    • I don't like Lori from comic.

        Loading editor
    • My list:

      Rick : Comics

      Morgan : Show

      Duane : Neither

      Shane : Show

      Carl : Comics

      Lori : Comics

      Andrea : Comics

      Carol : Show

      Glenn : Show

      Dale : Comics

      Sophia : Comics

      Jim : Show

      Amy : Show

      Tyreese : Comics

      Hershel : Show

      Maggie : Show

      Billy Greene (Comics) / Beth Greene (Show) : Billy Greene

      Otis : Show

      Patricia : Neither

      Axel : Comics

      Michonne : Equality

      The Governor : Comics

      Martinez : Neither

      Bob : Show

      Ben & Billy (comics) / Lizzie & Mika (Show) : Lizzie & Mika

      Abraham : Comics

      Eugene : Comics

      Rosita : Show

      Chris (Comics) / Gareth (Show) : Neither

      Gabriel : Show

      Aaron : Show

      Eric : Comics

      Heath : Comics

      Douglas (Comics) / Deanna (Show) : Deanna

      Regina (Comics) / Reg (Show) : Reg

      Scott : Show

      Tobin : Show

      Nicholas : Comics

      Bruce : Neither

      Spencer : Neither

      Denise : Comics

      Jessie : Show

      Pete : Neither

      Olivia : Neither

      Jesus : Comics

      Dwight : Comics

      Harlan : Comics

      Gregory : Neither

      Kal : Neither

      Eduardo : Neither

      Negan : Show

      Ezekiel : Comics

      Richard : Show

      Sherry : Show

      Laura : Comics

        Loading editor
    • Rick Grimes (Comic)
      Carl Grimes (Comic)
      Lori Grimes (Comic)
      Andrea Grimes (Comic)
      Maggie Greene (TV)
      Glenn Rhee (TV)
      Dale (Comic)
      Shane Walsh (TV)
      Tyreese (Comic)
      Hershel Greene (Comic) *Southern christian bastard*
      Morgan Jones (Comic) *Morgan from the TV is too different IMO, idk I just don't like him too much*
      Carol (Comic) *Same as Morgan*
      Michonne (TV) *I like both but TV Michonne is a bit more interesting*
      Brian Blake/Philip Blake (Brian Blake Comic) *Why does the TV governor have more votes!?*
      Bob Stookey (Comic) *If I hadn't read the novel series comic Bob would be the last person I would ever pick but he becomes such an awesome character after the prison arc and I can go as far as to say he is one of my favourite characters.
      Abraham Ford (Comic)
      Eugene Porter (Comic)
      Rosita Espinosa (TV)
      Caesar Ramon Martinez (Comic)
      Axel (Comic)
      Jim (TV)
      Amy (TV)
      Lilly Caul (Comic)
      Sophia (Comic)
      Otis (TV)
      Patricia (Comic)
      Ben/Billy or Lizzie/Mika (Lizzie/Mika TV)
      Claimers (TV)
      Prison Battle (Comic)
      Rick losing his hand (Don't Care)
      Judith outliving her comic counterpart (Don't Care)
      Terminus (TV)
      Deanna (TV) *Douglas wasn't as memorable*
      Nicholas (Comic) *Looks like 20 people forgot how to click comic smh*
      Anderson Family (TV)
      Gabriel Stokes (Comic)
      Aaron (Comic)
      Duane Jones (Comic)
      Allen (Comic)
      Donna (Comic)
      Billy/Beth Greene (Billy Comic)
      Andrew (Comic)
      Dexter/Oscar (Dexter Comic)
      Thomas Richards/Tomas (Thomas Richards Comic)
      Mike (TV)
      Terry (TV)
      Stevens (Comic)
      Negan (Comic)

      I could go through every character but that would get boring, anyway those are my picks.

        Loading editor
      • Rick Grimes - TV
      • Judith Grimes - TV
      • Carl Grimes - TV
      • Lori Grimes - Comic
      • Shane Walsh - TV
      • Morgan Jones - TV
      • Jenny Jones - TV
      • Duane Jones - TV
      • Glenn Rhee - TV
      • Dale Horvath - Comic
      • Jim - TV
      • Carol Peletier - Comic
      • Sophia Peletier - Comic
      • Andrea Harrison - Comic
      • Amy Harrison - TV
      • Maggie Greene - TV
      • Beth Greene (TV)/Billy Greene (Comic) - Comic Billy Greene
      • Hershel Greene - TV
      • Shawn Greene - Comic
      • Arnold Greene - Comic
      • Patricia - TV
      • Otis - TV
      • Michonne - TV
      • Mike - TV
      • Terry - TV
      • Axel - Comic
      • Oscar (TV)/Dexter (Comic) - TV Oscar
      • Andrew - Comic
      • Tomas (TV)/Thomas Richards (Comic) - Comic Thomas Richard
      • Caesar Ramon Martinez - TV
      • Stevens - Comic
      • Philip Blake (TV)/Brian Blake (Comic) - TV Philip Blake
      • Penny Blake - Comic
      • Sasha Williams (TV)/Julie Williams (Comic) - TV Sasha Williams
      • Tyreese Williams - Comic
      • Allen - Comic
      • Ben - Comic
      • Donna - TV
      • Bob Stookey - TV
      • Lizzie Samuels (TV)/Ben (Comic) - TV Lizzie Samuels
      • Mika Samuels (TV)/Billy (Comic) - TV Mika Samuels
      • Tara Chambler (TV)/Lilly Chalmers (Novel) - TV
      • Lilly Chambler (TV)/April Chalmers (Novel)/Lilly Caul (Comic) - Comic Lilly Caul
      • Tony (TV)/Craig (Comic) - TV Tony
      • Joe (TV)/Andy (Comic) - TV Joe
      • Greg - TV
      • Theresa - Comic
      • Albert - TV
      • Mike (TV)/Charlie (Comic) - Comic Charlie
      • Martin (TV)/David (Comic) - TV Martin
      • Gareth (TV)/Chris (Comic) - TV Gareth
      • Gabriel Stokes - TV
      • Aaron - TV
      • Enid (TV)/Sophia Peletier (Comic) - TV Enid
      • Barabara - TV
      • Scott - TV
      • Heath - Comic
      • Bruce - Comic
      • Tobin - TV
      • Mikey - Comic
      • Olivia - Comic
      • Denise Cloyd - Comic
      • Nicholas - Comic
      • Annie - TV
      • Barnes - TV
      • Holly - Comic
      • Erin - TV
      • Richards - TV
      • Carter - TV
      • Eric Raleigh - Comic
      • Spencer Monroe - TV
      • Deanna Monroe (TV)/Douglas Monroe (Comic) - Comic Douglas Monroe
      • Reg Monroe (TV)/Regina Monroe (Comic) - TV Reg Monroe
      • Ron Anderson (TV)/Ron Anderson (Comic)/Sam Anderson (TV) - TV Ron Anderson
      • Jessie Anderson - TV
      • Peter Anderson - TV
      • Betsy - TV
      • David - TV
      • Owen (TV)/Derek (Comic) - TV Owen
      • Siddiq - TV
      • Negan - TV
      • Laura - Comic
      • Arat (TV)/Tara (Comic) - Comic Tara
      • Amber - TV
      • Mark - Comic
      • John - Comic
      • Gary - TV
      • David - TV
      • Emmett Carson - Comic
      • Joseph - TV
      • Chris - TV
      • George - TV
      • Molly - TV
      • Donnie - TV
      • Bud - TV
      • Dwight - Comic
      • Sherry - TV
      • Paul Rovia (TV)/Paul Monroe (Comic) - Comic Paul Monroe
      • Bertie (TV)/Brianna (Comic) - Comic Brianna
      • Kal - TV
      • Eduardo - TV
      • Gregory - TV
      • Crystal - TV
      • Oscar - Comic
      • Wesley - Comic
      • Harlan Carson - TV
      • Andy - TV
      • Ethan - TV
      • Ezekiel - TV
      • Alvaro - TV
      • Richard - TV
      • Benjamin - TV
      • Shiva - TV
      • Buttons - Comic
      • Hannah - TV
      • Criminal (TV)/Reggie (Comic) - Comic Reggie
      • Red Poncho Man (TV)/Liam (Comic) - Comic Liam
      • Prison Outskirts Survivor - Comic
      • Siggard's Family Horse (TV)/Rick's Horse (Comic)
        Loading editor
    • Honestly the only character that I thought was better in the comic is Heath.  The comics could definitely do alot better on character development, since they have SO many characters and each character only gets a chunk of spotlight.  The TV series on the other hand, has entire episodes based on the characters (Tara, Morgan, etc)

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message