• There have been many great characters to grace The Walking Dead over the 4 seasons, many did not make it, but out of all the main survivors that have been killed off the show which one would you bring back if you could? If i have left out any character you liked that was killed off then let me know. Any character you think deserved more screen time(t-dog anyone?) or the right to live on longer then preach about it on this board!

    Which Character would you bring back?
     
    37
     
    12
     
    71
     
    95
     
    23
     
    4
     
    3
     
    4
     
    28
     
    4
     
    4
     
    3
     
    10
     
    1
     
    6
     
    2
     
    11
     
    2
     
    1
     
    1
     
    3
     
    3
     
    0
     
    2
     
    2
     
    1
     
    1
     
    12
     
    90
     
    3
     

    The poll was created at 02:20 on March 17, 2014, and so far 439 people voted.
      Loading editor
    • Poor Mika :(

        Loading editor
    • Hershel

        Loading editor
    • yay #team hershel

        Loading editor
    • Mika, she would've  deserved to come back. Killed by her crazy bi*ch as* sister.

        Loading editor
    • i feel like the only reason so many people voted Mika is because the episode where she dies just aired tonight

        Loading editor
    • I can't pick more than 1 so,

      Lizzie (voted)

      Mika

      Andrea

      Shane

      Zach

      Patrick

        Loading editor
    • I voted for Mika because she didn't deserve to die. :( Mika is kinda like Clem from Season 1 of the Video Game

        Loading editor
    • Id bring back3.Merle, Hershel and T-Dog

        Loading editor
    • Philip is awesome

        Loading editor
    • 62.44.134.239 wrote:
      Philip is awesome

      lol whatever you say man, i just put The Governor there for the hell of it, and also becuz a lot of people weirdly like him, i thought he was a perfect antagonist....

      I personally voted for Merle but i'd bring back Hershel, T-Dog, and Andrea as well.

        Loading editor
    • None. All of the characters have led to where we are now and I wouldn't change any that.

        Loading editor
    • i know that, this is just hypothetical 

        Loading editor
    • Then I would pick Andrea. She is the only major character whose death was unnecessary.

        Loading editor
    • Hershel!!!! This is WalkingDead1998. I've disconnected the profile, which can never work ever again.

        Loading editor
    • Edgeofnight wrote:
      Then I would pick Andrea. She is the only major character whose death was unnecessary.

      i agree there, only reason Dale was killed off early was Jeffrey Demunn didn't want to be a part of the show since Darabont left

        Loading editor
    • Mika - since her sister went to crazy town I was hoping that Mika would be a nice replacement for Sophia - but then I realized someone had to be a Billy to TV's Ben

        Loading editor
    • Shumpert!

        Loading editor
    • i wish they actaully would of shown us Shumpert's death, Martinez is just like "Eh, he's dead" then they all go on with their lives

        Loading editor
    • Adam Up Bxtch wrote:
      i wish they actaully would of shown us Shumpert's death, Martinez is just like "Eh, he's dead" then they all go on with their lives

      He only had like 3 lines. 

        Loading editor
    • i know but he lives as well as Martinez so i thought they would have had something planned for him next season but they're like nahhh. They wasted Morales as well in S1 i thought they would of brought him back by now or shown us his fate

        Loading editor
    • Adam Up Bxtch wrote:
      i know but he lives as well as Martinez so i thought they would have had something planned for him next season but they're like nahhh. They wasted Morales as well in S1 i thought they would of brought him back by now or shown us his fate

      The walking dead TV show needs to take a lesson from the comic and leave Morales up to question. Loose ends make things more realistic.

        Loading editor
    • The way they brought Merle back for S3 was pretty clever, i would of liked him to be alive still or atleast survived to Too Far Gone and been the one to be decapped instead of Hershel, how Daryl told Michonne she should stop looking and then start blaming himself even more than he already does if his brother would of been the one to be killed in Too Far Gone, and then Give Hershel his actual death from the comics where he is holding one of his kids(it could be Beth having been shot in the tv show)and being just straight up shot by The Governor, Merle's death in S3E15 was pretty good though

        Loading editor
    • Merle wasn't accepted by the prison group. they tolerated him for daryl's sake, but nothing more.

        Loading editor
    • Mika really could have filled the role of Sophia from the comics. Her and carl would be a strange relationship, but accepted nevertheless

        Loading editor
    • 98.15.191.209 wrote:
      Mika really could have filled the role of Sophia from the comics. Her and carl would be a strange relationship, but accepted nevertheless

      As of now, no character is set up to take Sophia's place. Mika... I don't know what word I'm looking for here, but she just wasn't fit for the role plus we needed a Ben/Billy event for the tv show.

        Loading editor
    • Edgeofnight wrote:
      Adam Up Bxtch wrote:
      i wish they actaully would of shown us Shumpert's death, Martinez is just like "Eh, he's dead" then they all go on with their lives
      He only had like 3 lines. 

      SO TRUE CAN'T STOP LAUGHING! HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHA

        Loading editor
    • Since I can't vote more than 1, I would revive:

      Merle

      T-Dog

      Hershel

      Mika

        Loading editor
    • i'll be honest i feel sorry for mika and hershel but still merle made the show better

      so when he was alive the show was better 100%

        Loading editor
    • I would Bring Back Hershel,Sophia,Mika,Dale,Andrea,Maybe..Okay Amy,And Probably Lizzie, she could use some Help

        Loading editor
    • Oh I forgot T-Dog..oh and both of Beth's Boyfriends anfpd Leave The Govener Dead

        Loading editor
    • I would revive lizzie for the reason she was kind of bad ass and caring especially to mika

      (I know she killed her but she just misunderstood things) despite being crazy and I'd like it better if she would be helped regarding her mental illness instead of being shot in the head

      I'd also revive mika(seriously, she doesn't deserve that death), hershel(he was like the caring grandpa for everyone), and T-dog(he was badd ass in a way

        Loading editor
    • the 0 votes on lori made me laugh so hard

        Loading editor
    • Adam Up Bxtch wrote:
      There have been many great characters to grace The Walking Dead over the 4 seasons, many did not make it, but out of all the main survivors that have been killed off the show which one would you bring back if you could? If i have left out any character you liked that was killed off then let me know. Any character you think deserved more screen time(t-dog anyone?) or the right to live on longer then preach about it on this board!
      Which Character would you bring back?
       
      37
       
      12
       
      71
       
      95
       
      23
       
      4
       
      3
       
      4
       
      28
       
      4
       
      4
       
      3
       
      10
       
      1
       
      6
       
      2
       
      11
       
      2
       
      1
       
      1
       
      3
       
      3
       
      0
       
      2
       
      2
       
      1
       
      1
       
      12
       
      90
       
      3
       

      The poll was created at 02:20 on March 17, 2014, and so far 439 people voted.


      Mika had potential.

        Loading editor
    • I would bring back Hershel,T-Dog and Sophia

        Loading editor
    • just merle

        Loading editor
    • Give me Merle or give me death.

        Loading editor
    • Hershel =[

        Loading editor
    • I liked Randall, he had potential, just like Mika did.They both had deaths that were far too sad for me,especially Mika's.

      Randall's death was something he didn't derserved, and I really hoped that they would've at least let him go after they brutally tortured him the barn. And the fact that half of the group didn't even know he was in there made me super pissed.

      Ugh, screw Shane btw I loved it when he died lol

        Loading editor
    • Even though she's not on the list, I would bring back Jeanette because she had potential to become an good character. I was hoping that she would become the next moral compass of the group. Sad that she disappeared in "Inmates", she wasn't even seen as one of the walkers/corpses on the bus, and is assumed dead.

        Loading editor
    • 98.67.246.162 wrote:
      Even though she's not on the list, I would bring back Jeanette because she had potential to become an good character. I was hoping that she would become the next moral compass of the group. Sad that she disappeared in "Inmates", she wasn't even seen as one of the walkers/corpses on the bus, and is assumed dead.

      Who the heck is Jeanette?

        Loading editor
    • Benzaco wrote:
      the 0 votes on lori made me laugh so hard

      HAHAHA! As soon as i saw your comment i realized as well, her having 0 votes is the way it should be....

        Loading editor
    • Adam Up Bxtch wrote:
      Benzaco wrote:
      the 0 votes on lori made me laugh so hard
      HAHAHA! As soon as i saw your comment i realized as well, her having 0 votes is the way it should be....

      can she have -1 votes

        Loading editor
    • thanks person who up 1 vote for lori

        Loading editor
    • Siamesedream1 wrote:
      98.67.246.162 wrote:
      Even though she's not on the list, I would bring back Jeanette because she had potential to become an good character. I was hoping that she would become the next moral compass of the group. Sad that she disappeared in "Inmates", she wasn't even seen as one of the walkers/corpses on the bus, and is assumed dead.
      Who the heck is Jeanette?

      Look her up on the wiki. She has her own page and everything.

        Loading editor
    • Edgeofnight wrote:

      Adam Up Bxtch wrote:
      i wish they actaully would of shown us Shumpert's death, Martinez is just like "Eh, he's dead" then they all go on with their lives

      He only had like 3 lines. 

      But he did shoot that 50 cal on the humvee

        Loading editor
    • Merle, Hershel, T-Dog,

      In that order. I feel like Merle and T-Dog were killed off too early, and I would have liked to see Hershel live a bit longer.

        Loading editor
    • I don't really know why I didn't want Martinez to die. I just was super pissed when the Governor killed him, and I liked his character.

        Loading editor
    • Would have been nice if Merle was one of Joe's Maurauders and not one of the Governor's men. It would have made the finding Rick story a whole lot more interesting. I'm enjoying it so far but it would have been greater if Merle was introduced with them as they seem to be more similar to him. I do hope that Rooker will appear in the spin-off show. If we could vote on who we could have in the spin-off shown then I'd choose Rooker or Wyatt Russell.

        Loading editor
    • I voted for Hershel.  Not necessarily because I want him back for good, I just hated the way he died.  I felt like his character should have died with a little more honor than that.  

        Loading editor
    • Hershel's death will defiantly be one of the most memorable deaths in the show

        Loading editor
    • I would pick Hershel, but I feel like he would be better off as dead for the development of other characters, so I chose Mika. Dont get me wrong, Hershel was an awesome character.

        Loading editor
    • Martinez

      Merle

      Shumpert

      Axel

      Oscar

        Loading editor
    • I always felt that Oscar died too soon, he was a good character and could've played a bigger role, but Rick just had to hallucinate at that moment and I also thought that Merle's death was kind of stupid, he basically died for nothing.

        Loading editor
    • Yes, Oscar died too soon. I think the show did not want Tyreese and Oscar around at the same time or they felt that TF could not escape Woodbury without a loss to the group.

      This is hard - I love Shane and Merle both. Shane's death was good for Rick's development and growth. I think Merle still had some unfinished business (especially with his brother)

        Loading editor
    • I would bring back Beth Greene

        Loading editor
    • I gotta go with Merle. He was one of those characters that was good in small doses. I would have paired him with Carol or Daryl after the fall of the prison but I don't think he would have gone along with Eugene's cure. Rednecks have a healthy skepticism of intellectuals and Merle liked the world the way it was.

        Loading editor
    • Abe

        Loading editor
    • andrea, lilly or beth.

        Loading editor
    • Jack7809 wrote:
      andrea, lilly or beth.

      Agree with you on all of those three! Andrea's death was not supposed to happen at all, Lilly barely got any development and the only development she got was having her daughter Meghan being killed by a walker. And Beth's story is just not clear and her body is still missing to this day

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message